Tuesday, 13 November 2012

Lord's Command or Personal Choice?




Having looked at the similarities and differences of the dietary requirements of the two monotheistic religions (Islam and Judaism), I wonder if similar rules apply to the third monotheistic religion (Christianity). I remember coming across one saying, that if a Muslim were to eat from a Christian or Jew, then he/she could trust a Jewish meal. In the back of my mind I used to ponder on the meaning of this saying but never fully grasped the logic behind it. By looking at Halal and Kosher, it became clear what it meant, i.e. both diets follow similar rituals for animal slaughter and pork is strictly forbidden in both religions. But is it the same in Christianity? Some of my Christian friends and neighbours do eat pork, but some don't. Upon asking, the answer I get is 'pork is forbidden in Christianity but it comes down to personal choice'. For me this doesn't make sense, if something is forbidden in a religion then where does this 'personal choice' fit in. As much as I longed for clarity, I never had a clear answer, so I decided to dedicate this post to find out whether ‘Pork in Christianity’ is forbidden or not. By typing 'Pork in Christianity' in Google, I found an endless list of articles, forums and blogs on the topic discussing whether it is allowed or forbidden, and most importantly why Christians eat it. Some of the online sites I consulted were;
From these articles and forums I did not find a clear cut answer. What I wanted to know was whether eating pork is strictly forbidden or not in Christianity. I discovered that it was forbidden in the Old Testament but in the New Testament there is leniency towards personal choice. For someone who seeks a definite answer leniency doesn't seem adequate. Still confused, I searched video clips to shed light on the topic. I found many video clips discussing this topic from different perspectives. I was intrigued by the following videos;
and


The following videos highlight why consuming pork is forbidden in religions as well as how it is harmful for human health. Very interesting facts! Indeed everything has a valid reason in God's Law. 


and

After watching these videos, it is clear that originally pork was forbidden in Christianity, but it is not conveyed as a religious requirement across some Christian sects as shown in this table; 
 
When it comes to eating, some Christians follow their own personal choice. Can personal choice take over the requirements of religion?

2 comments:

  1. I couldn't agree with you more. I feel if religion prohibits consumption of a particular food it should be prohibited. I don't understand if one scripture bans pork how can another scripture belonging to the same religion allow pork? This tells me that there is a discrepancy between the two scriptures. What does anyone else think?

    ReplyDelete
  2. As far as I understood this topic, the New Testament does not clearly mentions that pork is allowed. It is only how different individuals translated or picked out the content without context to suit their own personal choice. It is quite confusing and sad but it all depends on own understanding of scriptures, some will understand it in one way and the others in the other.

    ReplyDelete